Randi was bemoaning the lost family brisket recipe - allow this goy who grew up on the Upper West Side (800 WEA) in the '60's to help out.
GROSSINGER's Brisket is a traditional Passover recipe and can be found here:
http://bit.ly/dBZjYCThe key to making a tender brisket is not to rush the process. This is a cut of meat that is not tender - and cuts of this nature require a long cooking process - and, traditional Passover Brisket is prepared as a braised dish (tightly covered pot with stock/liquid at all times). That means low heat (I'd vary the linked recipe by reducing the oven temp to 300 f and increasing the cooking time) and liquid. You want to convert the collagen (connective tissue in the beef) into gelatin and that requires low and slow cooking. When you braise a brisket - remember that there is no "overcooking" possible so long as the dutch oven/braising pot remains covered and always has a good supply of liquid. The test for doneness is that "fork tender" - not some arbitrary time in the oven. You cook it until it is done - be it 3 hours or 10 hours - it's not done until it is tender.
There is an easy way to make a smaller brisket - have the butcher cut a flat-plate (top of the brisket) down to 2-3 lbs and buy a big crockpot. Start the brisket just before you go to bed and plan on having it at dinner time the next day. That's about an 18 hour braise - you won't have tough brisket and all that you will have to do is to adjust the veggies and seasonings to come up with the new favorite family brisket. It is foolproof as long as it never goes dry!
FWIW, the brisket features front and center in the haute cuisine of the midwest and southwest in the form of smoked brisket barbecue. I've smoked hundreds of pounds of brisket in my life and can tell you that a tender smoked brisket requires a decent spice rub, a good smoker that can hold a solid 165f while heating wood to the smoking point. My typical smoking time runs 18-24 hrs and I do spray the brisket with Apple Juice about once an hour for 10 hours and wrap the brisket in aluminum foil for the last 6 hours of cooking. Tender and flavorful - and an entirely different result than the braised brisket. Now that I'm in LA, my son has the smoker back in KC....
The next time that you visit Kansas City, you should try the smoked brisket "burnt ends" (not actually "burnt") at Arthur Bryant's
http://www.arthurbryantsbbq.com/ - Calvin Trillin declared in Playboy magazine that "...the single best restaurant in the world is Arthur Bryant's Barbeque at 18th & Brooklyn in Kansas City."
GRO